واکاوی پیوند متن و تصویر در منطق‌الطیر عطار(مطالعه موردی: نسخه خطی 1261ق)

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانش‌آموخته کارشناسی‌ارشد، گروه تصویرسازی، موسسه آموزش عالی فردوس، مشهد، ایران

2 استاد مدعو، گروه باستان‌شناسی و تاریخ، دانشکده ادبیات و علوم انسانی، دانشگاه دولتی نیشابور، ایران

چکیده

بیان مسئله: منطق‌الطیر اثر منظومِ عطار، دربردارنده محتوای فرازمینی و تجلی روحیات و گرایش‌های عرفانی است. در طی ادوار مختلف نسخه‌هایی از منطق‌الطیر تولید شده است. یکی از نسخه‌های خطی مصور بسیار محدود این اثر، در دوره قاجار تولید و امروزه در کتابخانه ملی ایران نگهداری می‌شود و تاکنون تصاویر آن مورد نقد و تحلیلِ پژوهشی قرار نگرفته است.

هدف: بررسی ریشه‌های خلق تصاویر نسخه خطی 1261ق منطق‌الطیر (محفوظ در کتابخانه ملی با شماره بازیابی 19039)، در راستای بازنمایی و ضریب تأثیر گفتمان بصری تولیدی از روایت مکتوب و بررسی میزان وفاداری تصویرگر به پیشامتن، مبنی بر نقد تکوینی.

سؤال: سؤال کل‌گرایانه پژوهش بر این محور قرار دارد که تصویرسازی‌های نسخه 1261ق تا چه میزان به حفظ اصالت و یا تغییر گفتمان روایی در گفتمان بصری منطق‌الطیر توجه داشته است؟ و در این بین به‌صورت جزگزایانه، میزان تأثیر پیشامتن بر متن نهایی، صحنه‌پردازی‌های تصویری و ویژگی‌های ظاهری شخصیت‌های موجود در این نسخه چگونه بازنمایی شده است؟

روش: با بهره‌گیری از روش توصیفی-تحلیلی و مبنی بر چارچوب نظری نقد تکوینی به بررسی جامعه موردمطالعه (10 تصویر) پرداخته شده است.

نتیجه‌گیری: تصویرسازِ ناشناسِ این اثر از اصول تصویری دوره خود (دوره اول قاجار) آگاهی کامل داشته و از تمامی نکات و ویژگی‌های این دوره در تصویرسازی‌هایش استفاده نموده است. از سویی دیگر، تصاویر داستان به‌طورکلی با متن اشعار مطابقت دارد، اما تصویرگر در شخصیت‌پردازی و تعداد شخصیت‌ها، فضاسازی و به تصویر کشیدن حالات روحی و جسمی شخصیت‌ها به‌طور کامل به متن پایبند نبوده و در این بین هنجارهای سیاسی، اجتماعی، فرهنگی و هنری و سبک شخصی هنرمند، مؤثر بوده است.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

Analyzing the link between text and image in Attar's Mantegh Alteyr (case study: manuscript 1261 AH)

نویسندگان [English]

  • sara ghafariansadr 1
  • Mostafa lalshateri 2
1 Master's student, Department of Illustration, Ferdows Institute of Higher Education, Mashhad, Iran
2 Visiting lecturer, Department of Archeology and History, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, University of Neyshabur, Iran
چکیده [English]

Statement of the problem: Attar's Mantegh Alteyr contains extraterrestrial content and the manifestation of mystical spirits and tendencies. During different eras, versions of Mantegh Alteyr have been produced. One of the very limited illustrated manuscripts of this work was produced in the Qajar period and is kept in the National Library of Iran today, and its images have not been analyzed by research.

Purpose: to investigate the origins of the creation of images in the 1261 AH manuscript of Mantegh Alteyr (preserved in the National Library with retrieval number 19039), in line with the representation and impact factor of the visual discourse produced from the written narrative, and to investigate the degree of fidelity of the illustrator to the original text, based on formative criticism.

Question: The holistic question of the research is based on how much the illustrations of the 1261 AH version paid attention to preserving the originality and changing the narrative discourse in the visual discourse of Mantegh Alteyr. And in the meantime, how is the influence of the pre-text on the final text, the visual scenes and the appearance characteristics of the characters in this version represented?

Method: By using the descriptive-analytical method and based on the theoretical framework of formative criticism, the study community (10 images) has been investigated.

Conclusion: The anonymous illustrator of this work was fully aware of the pictorial principles of his period (first Qajar period) and used all the points and features of this period in his illustrations. On the other hand, the images of the story generally correspond to the text of the poems, but the illustrator did not fully adhere to the text in characterizing and the number of characters, creating atmosphere and depicting the mental and physical states of the characters, and in the meantime political, social, and cultural norms and the artist's art and personal style has been effective.



Statement of the problem: Attar's Mantegh Alteyr contains extraterrestrial content and the manifestation of mystical spirits and tendencies. During different eras, versions of Mantegh Alteyr have been produced. One of the very limited illustrated manuscripts of this work was produced in the Qajar period and is kept in the National Library of Iran today, and its images have not been analyzed by research.

Purpose: to investigate the origins of the creation of images in the 1261 AH manuscript of Mantegh Alteyr (preserved in the National Library with retrieval number 19039), in line with the representation and impact factor of the visual discourse produced from the written narrative, and to investigate the degree of fidelity of the illustrator to the original text, based on formative criticism.

Question: The holistic question of the research is based on how much the illustrations of the 1261 AH version paid attention to preserving the originality and changing the narrative discourse in the visual discourse of Mantegh Alteyr. And in the meantime, how is the influence of the pre-text on the final text, the visual scenes and the appearance characteristics of the characters in this version represented?

Method: By using the descriptive-analytical method and based on the theoretical framework of formative criticism, the study community (10 images) has been investigated.

Statement of the problem: Attar's Mantegh Alteyr contains extraterrestrial content and the manifestation of mystical spirits and tendencies. During different eras, versions of Mantegh Alteyr have been produced. One of the very limited illustrated manuscripts of this work was produced in the Qajar period and is kept in the National Library of Iran today, and its images have not been analyzed by research.

Purpose: to investigate the origins of the creation of images in the 1261 AH manuscript of Mantegh Alteyr (preserved in the National Library with retrieval number 19039), in line with the representation and impact factor of the visual discourse produced from the written narrative, and to investigate the degree of fidelity of the illustrator to the original text, based on formative criticism.

Question: The holistic question of the research is based on how much the illustrations of the 1261 AH version paid attention to preserving the originality and changing the narrative discourse in the visual discourse of Mantegh Alteyr. And in the meantime, how is the influence of the pre-text on the final text, the visual scenes and the appearance characteristics of the characters in this version represented?

Method: By using the descriptive-analytical method and based on the theoretical framework of formative criticism, the study community (10 images) has been investigated.

Conclusion: The anonymous illustrator of this work was fully aware of the pictorial principles of his period (first Qajar period) and used all the points and features of this period in his illustrations. On the other hand, the images of the story generally correspond to the text of the poems, but the illustrator did not fully adhere to the text in characterizing and the number of characters, creating atmosphere and depicting the mental and physical states of the characters, and in the meantime political, social, and cultural norms and the artist's art and personal style has been effective.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Mantegh Alteyr
  • Qajar period painting
  • Formative criticism
  • Pretext
  • Text