Ferdows Art

Ferdows Art

Comparative study on physical characteristics of Urban walls (Cases studies: Bala and Paein Khiaban street , Mashhad as well as Tarbiat, Tabriz)

Document Type : Article Research Original

Authors
1 Assistant Professor of Architecture Department, Ferdows Institute of Higher Education, Mashhad, Iran
2 MA of Architecture, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Statement of the problem: Nowadays, In Iran, due to the lack of coordination between the walls, the issue of urban facades and their role in identifying the body of the city has become very critical. Since these views play a key role in transmitting the culture of the people and strengthening the urban image, examining their features and developing design principles based on it is important. In the meantime, examining and recognizing the historical walls in each period, which are an integral part of the city's memory, culture, and identity, and the analysis of the components affecting their design are some of the things that help us achieve this objective as much as possible. What is considered as an important and influential factor in the city and its appearance are urban walls, and this is what is happening today, especially in contemporary Iran, due to the visual disturbance of the appearance of cities and the lack of unity and coordination in them. It is regarded as a critical challenge to be addressed. Urban Landscape was first proposed by Thomas Sharp in 1948 in his Oxford study. But the visual encounter with the urban landscape in John Nash's work at the beginning of the 19th century was seen in the Olive work at the end of the 19th century. The philosophy of modern urban theory is entirely dependent on Gordon Cologne's theory. Gordon Cullen believes that the urban landscape can not only be understood technically but also requires aesthetic sensitivity. Although attention to the urban landscape is mainly a visual phenomenon, at the same time it evokes memories, reminds experiences, and creates emotional reactions.
Urban walls can be a factor in the unity and identity of the city and affect the perception of the audience. Urban facades can express the culture of the city and be the link between man, his culture, and the urban body, so examining and recognizing the historical walls of the city, which are an integral part of the historical memory of cities, is very important in preserving values. Culture is also the restoration of the identity of contemporary cities. In this regard, the present study examines the physical characteristics of the walls of the two historical periods in Iran to recognize the commonalities and differences between them and understand the design characteristics of urban walls of that time.
Aim: Understanding the indicators and characteristics used in the design of historic streets leads us to formulate the principles of designing the current urban walls, which is a continuation of the historical identity of our cities. In this study, the Bala and Paein Khiaban streets of Mashhad, which was formed during the Safavid period and at the end of the Qajar period (early Pahlavi), the facade of this wall has become registered as cultural heritage, as well as the Tarbiat St. in Tabri, belongs to the first Pahlavi era, have been studied. The purpose of reviewing and comparing these two historical walls is to gain an understanding of the differences between the two periods in the construction of urban walls and also to achieve the commonalities of these walls to find a model for building and designing contemporary urban walls. Having a model and recognizing the characteristics of valuable historical buildings, especially urban walls, which are the first layers of people's encounter with the city and understanding its identity, can sometimes be considered important to identify contemporary constructions.
According to the studies conducted so far, no comparative comparison has been made between the urban walls of the Qajar and Pahlavi periods, but there are research projects that have compiled information, document the urban walls and analyzed them. It is assumed that between these two streets with the necessary historical background in the two historical periods, some common principles and indicators can be evaluated in the continuity of the identity of the current cities.
Research Methods: To achieve this goal, the present study uses the physical characteristics of the facade, which includes sky and earth lines, background and shape, divisions and dominant lines, the width of parts, height, console, openings, color, the texture of materials and decorations. It is also an appendix and marks, evaluates the mentioned walls, and thus explains the physical characteristics of each by mentioning the common features and their differences. For this purpose, using analytical-descriptive, exploratory research method and also based on field studies in the form of direct observation and the presence of authors at the top and bottom of Mashhad Street and Tarbiat in Tabriz along with library studies, comparative study of the mentioned historical walls, this paper deals with the late Qajar period (Ayah Pahlavi) and the first Pahlavi period, recognizes the aspects of their differentiation and commonality, and explains their physical characteristics.
Conclusion: It is concluded that the views of these two walls from the perspective of the ground line, shape and background, width of parts, consoles, openings, horizontal and vertical divisions, extensions, signs, and panels have many similarities with each other, but their general difference is in the skyline, the materials differences in the height of the buildings and especially their decorations.
Keywords

Subjects


  1. - Abbaszadeh, Shahab, and Soda Tamri (2012). "Study and analysis of effective components on improving the spatial qualities of sidewalks in order to increase the level of social interactions of the case study, training axes and Valiasr Tabriz". Journal of Urban Studies, (4), 95- 104.

    - Afifi, Vahide. Talaei, Maryam (2014), Considering the Urban Elevation of Mashhad, based on Ornamentations, Materail and Teqniques. in collaboration with the Institute of Higher Education of Mashhad Secrets and the Cultural Heritage and Tourism Organization of Khorasan Razavi.

    - Afshar Naderi, Kamran. (2008), "Facade in Iranian Architecture", Memar, No. 51.

    - Archive of National Library and Archieves of Islamic Republic of Iran.

    - Amanat, Abbas (2004). Pivot of the unuiverse: Nasir al - din Shah Qajar and the Iranian monarchy 1831 - 1896, translated by Hassan Kamshad, Karnameh, Mehregan, Tehran.

    - Bani Massoud, Amir (2012). Contemporary Iranian Architecture, Century Architecture Publications, Tehran.

    - Baurnes, Alex (1987). Baurnes Travelogue: Travel to Iran during the reign of Fath Ali Shah Qajar, translated by Hassan Soltanifar, Astan Quds Razavi Publications, Mashhad.

    - Bemanian, Mohammad Reza, Mo'meni, Kourosh and Sultanzadeh, Hossein (2011). " Study of Innovations and Developments, Decorating and Tiling Designs Case study: Masjid-Madreseh OF Qajar ", Negareh, No. 18, pp. 35-47.

    - Bemanian, Mohammad Reza, Momeni, Kourosh and Sultanzadeh, Hossein (2011). " Comparative Study of Tiling Patterns in two Isfahan's Mosques- Schools: " Madrese Chaharbagh" and " Masjed-seyyed ", Comparative Studies of Art, No. 2, 1-15.

    - Carmona, Matthew. Heath, Tim and Tisdell, Tanzacastion (2009), Public places urban spaces the dimensions of urban design, translated by Fariba Gharaei, Tehran, University of the Arts.

    - Deilmann H, et al. )1987( Deilmann, H., Bickenabach, G. and Pfeiffer, H.; “Living in Cities”, Zurich .

    - Farokhi, Maryam (2010), "The role of pedestrian axes in the sustainable development of cities, a case study of Tarbiat sidewalk in Tabriz", Proceedings of the first conference on sustainable urban development in Iran, Tehran.

    - Ghobadian, Vahid (2004). Architecture of Tehran during Naseredin Shah period, Tehran, Pashtun Publishing.

    - Goodarzi, Morteza, (2009). Mirror of Imagination, Surah Mehr Publications, Tehran.

    - Jadid al-Islam, Mohammad Ali, and Farshad Abrishami (2012). Old Tabriz, Abrishamifar Publications, Tabriz.

    - Khosravi, Mohammad Baqher (1998). "Iranian Architecture in the Qajar Period", Art Quarterly, Tehran Center for Art Studies and Research, No. 36.

    - Kiyani, Mostafa (2004), Architecture of the First Pahlavi Period, Tehran, Institute of Contemporary Iranian History Studies Publications.

    - Kreimer, A, Arnold, M & Carlin, A (2003). Building Safer Cities: The Future of Disaster Risk, Disaster Risk Management Series – No.3.

    - Lang, John (2007). Urban design: a typology of procedures and products, translated by Seyed Hossein Bahreini, Tehran, University of Tehran Press.

    - Mashhadizadeh Dehaghani, Nasser (1994), An analysis of urban planning charactristics in Iran, Tehran, University of Science and Technology Publications.

    - McGregor Gore, c. (1987). Narrative of a Journey through the province of Khorasan on the N.W. Frontier of Afghanistan in 1875, translated by Majid Mehdizadeh, Astan Quds Cultural Deputy, Mashhad.

    - Modarres Razavi, Mohammad Taghi and others (2007), Mashhad at the beginning of the fourteenth solar century (known as the Shahpour School), edited and explained by Mehdi Seyedi. Mashhad: Pen song.

    - M. Scarce, J (1979). Function and decoration in Qajar Tilework, in Islam in the Balkans, Persian Art and Culture of the 18th and 19th centuries, ed. Jennifer M. Scarce (Edinburgh: Royal Scottish Museum, 75–86.

    - Naghizadeh, Mohammad, Zamani, Bahador and Karami, Islam (2010). Cultural considerations in shaping urban landscapes based on the structure of Iranian urban landscapes in the Islamic era, Hoviatshahr, No. 7, 61-74.

    - Pakzad, Jahanshah (2003), " Phenomenology of Residential Building Façade and the Evolution Process of its Expectations", Honar-ha-ye-Ziba, No. 14, 91-102.

    - Rezvani, Alireza, (2005), In Search of Mashhad Urban Identity, Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, Tehran.

    - Safamanesh, Kamran, Rashtchian, Yaghoub and Manadizadeh, Behrooz (1997). "Historical evolution of the urban passage of the passage in the city of Tabriz", Goftegoo Magazine, No. 18, 73-86.

    1. Seyedi, Mehdi (1999). History of Mashhad from the beginning to the Constitution, Jami Publications, Tehran.

    - Shahri, Jafar (2004). Old Tehran, Moin, Tehran.

    - Soltanzadeh, Hossein (1390). An Introduction to the History of the City and Urbanization in Iran, from the Ancient Period to 1986, Amir Kabir Publishing Institute, Tehran.

    - Tabatabai, Malek (2011). Urban facades and their roles in environmental quality, Armanshahr Publications, Tehran.

    - Zamani, Bahador, Aghajani Refah, Mehri, Khamenehzadeh, Hananeh and Abbasgholizadeh, Hakimeh (2008). Research study plan for organizing the historical-cultural axis of education. District 8 Municipality of Tabriz in collaboration with the Research Center for Restoration of Historic Buildings and Textures, Tabriz University of Islamic Arts.